What Are the Benefits of Conversion From a Mutual to a Stock Insurance Company?

If you don't understand the demutualization proposal, your agent can probably help.

Hemera Technologies/AbleStock.com/Getty Images

The financial services sector is intensely competitive, and even the strongest of companies must adapt to changing circumstances if they're going to thrive. For example, many mutual insurance companies choose to convert their ownership structure (owned by its members) into a stock-based structure (owned by its shareholders) through a process called demutualization. Demutualization benefits a company by allowing it to raise money by trading shares, which potentially leads to faster growth and a stronger company. Policyholders also benefit by receiving compensation for their ownership stake.


As a result of demutualization, mutual insurance company policyholders receive cash, shares of stock, increased insurance benefits or a combination of these benefits to compensate them for their ownership stake in the newly transitioned stock insurance company.

Mutual vs. Stock Companies

The first mutual insurance organizations were loose-knit groups of merchants who pooled emergency funds for their mutual benefit in case of fire. Modern mutual insurance companies are run as cooperatives, in some ways resembling credit unions.

Every policyholder is also a part owner in the company and enjoys better dividends or cash values when the company flourishes. Stock companies sell shares in the business, like other companies, and the shareholders own the company. This creates a potential conflict between the shareholders' interests and the policyholders' interests, and well-run companies are careful to address the needs of both groups.

Exploring the Impact of Demutualization

Although several of the industry's largest players are mutual companies, they operate at a disadvantage in the corporate marketplace. Borrowing is their only option for raising large quantities of capital, and it's not always possible to fund a proposed acquisition or expansion through borrowing. To overcome this difficulty, some companies choose to convert to a publicly traded structure, a process called "demutualization."

A majority of policyholders must vote to support the decision, and an initial public offering must be underwritten. The policyholders' stake in the new company is calculated through a formula that accounts for the quantity of insurance they own and the length of time they've made premium payments.

Advantages of Demutualization

Demutualization typically takes 18 to 24 months. Once the process is complete, the newly reorganized company can trade its shares on the open market and float new issues as needed to generate capital. That makes stock-based companies nimbler and better able to respond to changing market conditions. It's easier for them to make an acquisition, attract a takeover bid, or -- if necessary -- repel a takeover bid.

A stock company can benefit from any increase in its share price, as well as the performance of its own investment portfolio. At least in theory, it results in a stronger company that's capable of faster growth.

Assessing Policyholder Benefits

When a company proposes demutualization, policyholders are offered compensation for their ownership stake. The company's proposal will outline a variety of options, usually including a cash settlement, stock in the new company, increased cash value in your policies or a combination of several benefits.

Policyholders who accept stock in the new company continue to hold an ownership stake. Those who accept cash can reinvest it as they please. Any existing policies will remain unchanged, as long as they're kept in force.